HomeTechWhat Needs to Happen Before Your Organization Gets Rid of Old IT...

What Needs to Happen Before Your Organization Gets Rid of Old IT Equipment

Published on

Latest article

The best alternative gemstones for a unique engagement ring

While diamonds remain a popular choice for engagement rings, more couples are exploring alternative...

If you want to see how IT disposal goes wrong, you do not need to picture a hacker. You only need to picture a pallet of old servers being wheeled onto a truck while everyone in the building assumes somebody else already checked it.

That is more or less what the SEC described when it fined Morgan Stanley Smith Barney. According to the SEC’s 2022 announcement, the firm hired a moving and storage company with no data destruction experience to decommission thousands of hard drives and servers; some of those devices were later resold on an internet auction site with customer data still on them, and the firm agreed to a $35 million penalty over failures that put the personal information of approximately 15 million customers at risk. Most of the devices handed to the mover were never recovered.

Very little in that story is about the disposal itself. The shredding, the recycling, the resale- none of that is complicated. What went wrong is that a set of basic questions was never answered before the equipment left. 

So this guide is organized around those questions, phase by phase, in the order an organization would normally run into them. If you can answer each one with a name, a record or a document, you are in good shape. If you cannot, that is the spot where something is likely to go missing.

Phase 1: Questions to Answer Before Anyone Touches the Hardware

The first phase happens on paper and in meetings, and it is the one most often skipped, because it feels like it delays the “real” work of clearing out a room.

Who actually owns this decision?

Somebody has to be accountable for the whole disposal project, from the first spreadsheet to the last certificate, and it usually should not be the person who carries the boxes. In most organizations, the decision touches several groups:

  • IT, which knows what the equipment is and where it lives.
  • Information security, which decides what counts as sensitive data and how it must be destroyed.
  • Legal or compliance, which knows about retention rules, legal holds and industry regulations (HIPAA, SOX, FERPA, and so on, depending on the sector).
  • Finance, which carries the assets on the books and may want to see value recovered.

Facilities and procurement often get pulled in as well. The point is not to form a committee for every laptop. The point is that one named person signs off, and that the other groups have had a chance to say “wait” before anything is irreversible.

Is any of this equipment under a legal hold or a retention requirement?

This question is easy to forget and expensive to get wrong. If a drive holds records that fall under a litigation hold, an audit, or a retention schedule, destroying it can create a legal problem that is worse than a data breach. 

Before anything is wiped, legal or records management should confirm that the data on those devices either has been migrated somewhere else or is no longer required. It is also worth confirming that backups exist for anything the business still needs, because once a drive is shredded, there is no undo.

Does the equipment belong to you, or to a lessor?

Leased equipment usually has to go back to the leasing company, often in a specific condition and with specific parts, and the data on it is still your responsibility when it goes. Finance should also be told which owned assets are being retired, so the fixed asset register can be updated. A surprising number of disposal projects end with assets that are gone from the building but still sitting on the books.

Phase 2: Questions About What You Actually Have

The second phase is the inventory, and it is the spine of everything that comes after it. A good inventory prices the lot, tells you which devices need data destruction, and gives you something to check the vendor’s paperwork against later.

What exactly is in the room?

The standard to aim for is a serialized audit, which means every asset is recorded individually instead of being counted in bulk. For each item, that usually includes:

  • Make and model.
  • Serial number, plus your own asset tag if you use them.
  • Configuration (CPU, memory, drive count and capacity, network cards, power supplies).
  • Physical location, down to the rack or the storage cage.

“Forty servers, assorted” is not an inventory. “Forty servers” with forty serial numbers and forty configurations is. It is more work up front, but it is the only version of the list that anyone can verify later.

Which of these items actually hold data?

Not everything on the pallet carries the same data risk, and sorting this out early saves time and money. Hard drives, SSDs and backup tapes are the obvious ones. Less obvious are network switches and firewalls, which can hold configuration files, VLAN settings, logs and stored credentials, as well as phones, printers and copiers with internal storage.

On the other side, components like GPUs, CPUs and RAM do not store user data in a lasting way (memory contents clear when the power is removed), so they do not need the same destruction process as a drive. Flagging data-bearing devices at the inventory stage means the destruction step can be planned per device, instead of either shredding everything by default or, worse, missing something.

Does the count match what the records say?

Reconcile the physical inventory against your asset management system or CMDB before anything moves. Missing items should be explained now, while there is still time to look for them. In the same SEC case, a records reconciliation during a hardware refresh turned up a shortfall of 42 servers that may have held unencrypted customer data. You would much rather find a gap like that in your own reconciliation than in a regulator’s findings.

Phase 3: Questions About Condition and Value

Once you know what you have, the next question is what it is worth, and whether it should be resold, redeployed internally, or recycled. Equipment that still has resale value can offset part or all of the cost of a disposal project, but only if it is described accurately.

Does it work, and how do you know?

Condition grading for used IT equipment generally falls into a few plain categories:

  • Working (tested): the unit powers on, passes its self-test (POST) and boots, and the test result is recorded.
  • Untested: the unit has not been powered on or checked, so a buyer has to assume some risk.
  • For parts or not working: the unit fails testing or is known to be damaged, and its value is in its components.

Cosmetic condition (scratches, dents, missing bezels) is usually noted separately. The honest grade matters more than an optimistic one. Buyers who receive “working” equipment that does not boot tend to re-price the whole lot, including the units that were fine.

Is it complete?

Completeness has a bigger effect on value than most people expect. A server that ships with its drive caddies, rail kits, both power supplies, network cards and transceivers is a ready-to-use unit, and it is worth more than the same server that has been stripped for spare parts. 

Software licenses and management keys (for example, remote management licenses on servers) are also worth recording if they transfer with the hardware. Note what is present and what is missing for each serial number, rather than in a general comment at the bottom of the list.

How old is it, and how long has it been sitting?

Value is mostly driven by generation, age and buyer demand. Current or recent-generation servers, storage and networking gear usually attract more interest than equipment that is several generations old, and demand for some categories (for example, GPUs and AI accelerators) can shift quickly. 

One opinion we hold firmly: storage time is the most avoidable loss in this whole process. Equipment that sits in a closet for a year while a disposal decision is debated tends to lose value with every month, and nothing about it improves. If resale is on the table, it is usually better to make the decision and move the equipment sooner rather than later.

What will a buyer need to see?

If equipment is going to be resold, whether through a disposition partner or another channel, the listing or quote request should include enough detail for a buyer to price it without guessing. In practice that means:

  • Model, configuration and serial number for each unit.
  • The condition grade and any notes about defects or missing parts.
  • Clear photos of the front, the back, the ports and the model and serial labels.

A spreadsheet that matches your serialized audit, with photos linked to the serial numbers, is usually enough. The more specific the information, the less room there is for a price to change after the equipment arrives.

Phase 4: Questions About the Data on the Devices

This is the phase most people think of first, but it works much better when Phases 2 and 3 are already done, because by now you know exactly which devices carry data and which ones have resale value worth protecting.

Should each device be wiped or destroyed?

The choice usually comes down to two things: whether the device has resale value, and what your security policy requires.

  • Certified data wiping (overwriting or erasing the drive with verification) removes the data while keeping the drive usable, so it preserves resale value.
  • Physical destruction, such as shredding or crushing, is used when a drive has failed, cannot be wiped reliably, or when policy simply requires it for certain data.

The media type matters too. Degaussing works only on magnetic media such as hard disk drives and tape, and it does nothing to an SSD. SSDs and other flash storage need a manufacturer secure erase command, cryptographic erase (destroying the encryption key), or physical destruction, because ordinary overwriting is not dependable on flash due to how those drives spread data across their memory cells.

Should it happen on-site or off-site?

On-site wiping or shredding means drives never leave your building with data on them, which some regulated organizations prefer or require. Off-site processing is often more practical for large volumes, but then the transport step becomes part of your risk, and you need locked containers, a documented handoff and a clear record of who had the equipment at each point. 

Neither choice is wrong. What matters is that the decision is made deliberately, and written down, instead of being decided by whoever shows up with a truck.

How will each drive be tied back to its serial number?

This is the question that separates a defensible process from a hopeful one. Every data-bearing device should have its own record that connects the serial number to the method used, the date, and the result. 

If a drive is pulled from a server before wiping, the drive serial should still be linked to the server it came from. Without that link, a certificate that says “300 drives destroyed” does not prove that your 300 drives were the ones destroyed.

Phase 5: Questions About Who Takes It and What They Hand Back

The last phase is choosing who receives the equipment, and deciding in advance what paperwork you expect to get back. This is where the Morgan Stanley case fell apart, and it is also where most organizations have the least visibility, because the work happens out of sight.

How do you vet a disposition partner?

The Federal Trade Commission’s guidance on its Disposal Rule for consumer report information gives a useful starting point even for organizations it does not directly cover: it describes due diligence such as reviewing an independent audit of a disposal company’s operations and requiring that the company be certified by a recognized trade association. 

For electronics specifically, the EPA’s page on certified electronics recyclers explains that there are two accredited certification standards (R2 and e-Stewards), and that certified recyclers are held to the standard through continual oversight by an independent certifying body.

In practice, the questions to ask any prospective partner include:

  • Which certifications do you hold, and can we verify them in the certifying body’s public directory?
  • Where will our equipment actually be processed, and do you send any of it to downstream vendors?
  • How is equipment transported, and who has custody of it at each step?
  • What insurance do you carry for data and property in your care?

If a provider is vague about any of this, or claims a certification that you cannot find in a public directory, that is enough reason to keep looking.

What should a qualified partner hand back to you?

A qualified ITAD partner should return documentation that you can match line by line against the serialized inventory you built in Phase 2. At minimum, that means a serialized asset report that lists every item received, by serial number, with its outcome (resold, recycled or destroyed); a certificate of destruction or data sanitization that names each data-bearing device by serial number and the method used; and a chain of custody record showing when the equipment was picked up, who handled it and where it went. 

If anything was resold, there should also be an itemized settlement that ties each payment back to an asset. When those documents line up with your own list, an auditor can trace any single drive from your rack to its end state. Serial-level accountability of this kind is what Big Data Supply builds its IT asset disposition services around. 

It is an R2v3 and RIOS certified ITAD company that logs each asset by serial number from pickup, wipes or shreds data-bearing devices to the agreed standard, and closes out a disposition project with serial-level certificates of destruction, chain of custody records and payment for any equipment that still has resale value. Whichever ITAD provider you choose, the test is the same: if their paperwork cannot be reconciled with your inventory, the job is not finished.

A short reference: each phase and the record it should leave behind

PhaseThe question that must be answeredThe record it should produce
1. Before anyone touches the hardwareWho signs off, and is any data under hold or lease terms?Named owner, legal and retention clearance
2. InventoryWhat do we have, and which items hold data?Serialized audit, reconciled against the asset register
3. Condition and valueDoes it work, is it complete, what is it worth?Condition grades, completeness notes, photos
4. DataWipe or destroy, where, and how is each drive tracked?Per-device sanitization plan
5. HandoffWho takes it, and what comes back?Serialized report, certificates of destruction, chain of custody, settlement

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the first step before disposing of IT assets?

The first step is assigning one accountable owner and confirming with legal or records management that none of the data on the equipment is still required. After that, the most important practical step is a serialized inventory of every item, because every later decision depends on it.

Do all IT assets need data destruction?

No. Devices with persistent storage, such as hard drives, SSDs, tapes, and the storage inside switches, firewalls, phones and printers, need to be wiped or destroyed. Components such as GPUs, CPUs and RAM do not store user data once powered off, so they do not need the same treatment, although the systems they came out of still need to be checked for drives.

Is it better to wipe drives or shred them?

Wiping is usually the better choice when a drive works and has resale value, because it removes the data and keeps the drive usable. Shredding makes more sense when a drive has failed, when it cannot be reliably wiped, or when your policy requires physical destruction for certain kinds of data.

What paperwork should we keep after IT asset disposal?

Keep the serialized inventory you created, the vendor’s serialized asset report, certificates of destruction that list each data-bearing device by serial number, chain of custody records, and any settlement statements for resold equipment. Many organizations keep these for as long as their longest applicable records retention requirement.

How do we know if a disposal vendor is legitimate?

Check that the certifications they claim appear in the certifying body’s public directory, ask where the equipment will actually be processed and whether downstream vendors are involved, and ask to see a sample of their reporting before you sign. A legitimate vendor will be able to show you serial-level documentation without any difficulty.

The Part That Is Easy to Skip

Most of what goes wrong in IT disposal happens before the truck arrives: nobody owned the decision, nobody reconciled the count, nobody decided which drives held data, or nobody agreed in advance what paperwork would come back. 

None of those steps require special equipment. They require someone to ask the questions above while the equipment is still in your building and still in your control, because after it leaves, the only thing you will have is the record you made before it went.

Late Magazine

Popular Posts

Robert Attenborough: The Story Behind David Attenborough’s Son

While David Attenborough became a global icon, Robert Attenborough carved his own scientific legacy...

Nidal Al-Hamdani: The Untold Story Behind Saddam Hussein’s Wife

Nidal Al-Hamdani remains one of the most enigmatic figures connected to modern Iraqi history,...

Sherrill Redmon: The Untold Story of Mitch McConnell’s Ex-Wife

Sherrill Redmon is often recognized primarily as Mitch McConnell's first wife, but her legacy...

Gina Capitani: The Untold Story of Theo Von’s Mother

Gina Capitani may be best known as comedian Theo Von's mother, but her story...

More like this

The best alternative gemstones for a unique engagement ring

While diamonds remain a popular choice for engagement rings, more couples are exploring alternative...

Keeping an Indoor Cat’s Litter Box Clean and Odor-Free

Indoor cats live closely with their owners, and the litter box is the one...

Why Accent Chairs Do More Work Than Your Sofa

The sofa gets the credit, but the chairs do the work. A room with...